January 05, 2004
Smart people driving out action
Why Can't We Get Anything Done?:
"Companies often confuse talking with doing. They think that talking about doing something is the same thing as doing it! That planning is the same as doing. That giving presentations is the same as doing. That making reports is the same as doing. Or even that making a decision to do something is the same as doing it. All of those errors occur with alarming regularity in companies today.
Mistaking talk for action is worse than just a simple error: Talk can actually drive out action. Studies about the way that meetings actually work demonstrate that negative people are perceived as being smarter than positive people -- that is, being critical is interpreted as a sign of intelligence. You see this attitude in business all the time: The fastest way for me to seem smart is to cut you down. So you come up with an idea, and I come up with a thousand different reasons why that idea won't work. Now everyone sees you as dumb and me as smart -- and we've created an environment where no one wants to come up with ideas."
This gives an indication of why this country is paralyzed. Too many smart people from Polytechnique, ENA and Corps des Mines who know they are smart (they have been told so) and who make a living judging the actions of other less smart people. But there's worse: Not so smart people in France often try to boost their ego by imitating smart people.
That's what we call French wit: A lot of interesting conversations and little action. The Establishment of smart people.
Trackback Pings
I know that I'm not going to catch up with all interesting posts from Internet-cafe, but I'm still trying :) John Moore ( and long chain of others ) point to a quote from Art
Continue reading 'Quality the emerges in action'...
You can't entirely separate thinking from doing. But while you can't divorce them, you can make them sleep in separate rooms.
Continue reading 'Quantity vs Quality II'...
Lilia Efimova comments on my entry on Doing vs Analysing and links (via Martin Dugage) to this Fast Company article: Why Can't We Get Anything Done? This is a good summary of the points made in the book, The Knowing...
Continue reading 'Thinking/doing'...
Comments
No-one has commented on this entry (yet).
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)